Red, theory; black, fact
 |
| Midplane section of human brain annotated with the Brodmann areas, which are related to different functions |
People contract mental illness but animals seemingly do not, or at least not outside of artificial laboratory models such as the unpredictable, mild-stress rodent model of depression. A simple theory to account for this cites the paleontological fact that the human brain has been expanding at breakneck speed over recent evolutionary time and postulates that this expansion is ongoing at the present time, and that mental illness is the price we are paying for all this brain progress.
The Evolution of the Human Brain
In other words, the mentally ill may carry the unfavorable mutations that have to be selected out during this progress. The mutation rate in certain categories of mutation affecting human brain development may be elevated in modern humans by some sort of "adaptive" hot-spot system. "Adaptive" is in scare quotes to indicate that the adaptation inheres in changes in the standard deviation of traits, not the average, and is therefore not Lamarkian.
In brain evolution, the growth changes in the various parts very probably have to be coordinated somehow. There may not be any master program doing this coordination. Rather, the human brain would comprise scores of tissue "parcels," each with its own gene to control the final size that parcel reaches in development. This is consistent with the finding of about 400 genes in humans that participate in establishing body size. All harmonious symmetry, even left-right symmetry, would have to be painstakingly created by brute-force selection, involving the early deaths of millions of asymmetrical individuals.
Assuming that left and right sides must functionally cooperate to produce a fitness improvement, mutations affecting parcel growth must occur in linked, left-right pairs to avoid irreducible-complexity paradoxes. The crossing-over phenomenon in egg and sperm maturation may create these linked pairs of mutations, where the two mutations are identified with the two ends of the DNA segment that translocates. Since the two linked mutations are individually random, linkage per se does not eliminate asymmetry. That must be done by natural selection, as previously stated, so there is a subtlety here. Natural selection could equally well create adaptive asymmetry. The human heart and the claws of the fiddler crab are examples.
Functional Human Brain Anatomy
Most of the evolutionary expansion of the human brain appears to be focused on association cortex, which would implement if-then rules like those making up the knowledge bases familiar from the field of artificial intelligence. The "if" part of the rule would be evaluated in post-Rolandic cortex, i.e., in temporal and parietal association cortices, and the "then" part of the rule would be created by the pre-Rolandic association cortex, i.e., the prefrontal cortex. The white matter tracts running forward in the brain would connect the "if" part with the "then" part, and the backward running white-matter tracts would carry priming signals to get other rules ready to "fire" if they are commonly used after the rule in question.
Possible Disorders of Brain Growth
Due to such tight coordination, the ideal brain will have a fixed ratio of prefrontal cortex to post-Rolandic association cortex. However, the random nature of the growth-gene bi-mutations, perhaps at mutational hot-spots, permitting human brain evolution will routinely violate this ideal ratio, leading to the creation of individuals having either too much prefrontal cortex or too much temporal/parietal cortex. In the former case, prefrontal cortex will be starved of sensory input. In the latter case, sensory association cortex will be starved of priming signals feeding back from motoric areas.
Denervation supersensitivity occurs when the normal nerve supply to a muscle is interrupted, resulting in a rapid overexpression of acetylcholine receptors on the muscle. This is an adaptation to compensate for weak nerve transmission with a re-amplification of the signal by the muscle. Analogous effects have been found in areas of the cerebral cortex deprived of their normal supply of sensory signals, so the effect seems to be general.
In cases of genetically-determined frontal-parietal/temporal imbalance, the input-starved side would develop denervation supersensitivity, making it prone to autonomous, noise-driven nervous activity.
Differential Growth-Related Brain Disorders
If the growth excess is in sensory association cortex, this autonomous activity will manifest as hallucinations, resulting in schizophrenia. If the growth excess is in the prefrontal cortex, however, the result of the autonomous activity will be mania or a phobia.
The non-overgrown association cortex might secondarily develop the opposite of denervation supersensitivity as the result of continual bombardment with autonomous activity from the other side of the Rolandic fissure. This could account for the common observation of hypoprefrontality in cases of schizophrenia.
